Jonah Lehrer

Jonah Lehrer
File:Jonah Lehrer - Pop!Tech 2009 - Camden, ME.jpg Jonah Lehrer, 2009
Born	Jonah Richard Lehrer (1981-06-25) June 25, 1981 Los Angeles, CA
Occupation	blogger, book author and contributor
Nationality	American
Education	Columbia University, Wolfson College, Oxford
Alma mater	Columbia University
Period	2007-present
Genre	popular science
Subject	behavioural neuroscience
Notable works	Proust Was a Neuroscientist (HMH, 2007) How we Decide (HMH, 2009; recalled 2012) Imagine: How Creativity Works (HMH, 2012; recalled 2013)
Spouse	Sarah Liebowitz
Website
https://jonahlehrer.com

Jonah Lehrer (born Jonah Richard, June 25, 1981) is an American writer and speaker who, on the foundation of Columbia University neuroscience training and journalistic experience, and humanities coursework as a Rhodes Scholar at Wolfson College at Oxford, built a rapidly successful book, magazine, and blog writing career that integrated ideas from science and the humanities to broadly address aspects of human behaviour.

Lehrer's writing was originally praised, broadly, for its style and literary quality, while being criticised for its scientific content. His work appeared regularly at Wired.com and The New Yorker, as well as at other major popular online science sites. Over a period of a few years, Lehrer published three books, all with Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (HMH): Proust Was a Neuroscientist (2007), How We Decide (2009), and Imagine: How Creativity Works (2012).

In June 2012, reporters for New York Magazine and Slate published posts that several blogs of Lehrer's at The New Yorker reused portions of his own prior published work without acknowledgment, a practice known as "self-plagiarism," which brought broader scrutiny to his writing. In July 2013, journalist Michael C. Moynihan, on investigating Bob Dylan quotations he considered suspicious in Lehrer's HMH book Imagine, identified a number whose origin and authenticity he could not confirm. When confronted, Lehrer initially misled Moynihan as to their origins, but ultimately confessed to improperly combining published Dylan quotations, and to fully fabricating others. Attention to Lehrer's writing at Wired.com raised similar concerns, and investigation of a sample of Lehrer content there, by journalism professor Charles Seife of Columbia University, led Seife to observe that Lehrer had routinely recycled his work, plagiarised press releases and authored works, and seriously misused quotes and facts, and so to conclude that Lehrer had a reckless disregard for truth. In a statement through HMH on July 30, Lehrer publicly acknowledged the fabrications in Imagine; that same day, Lehrer resigned from the The New Yorker, and HMH announced it would take off-sale (recall) all published forms of Imagine. During the first weeks of August, further quotation issues in Imagine were reported (e.g., on its Penn & Teller material), HMH and others were reportedly engaged in broader investigations into Lehrer's work, and reports began to appear of comparable issues in Lehrer's earlier book, How We Decide. Wired.com severed its relationship with Lehrer at the end of August, following publication at Slate.com of the results of the Seife investigation of the Lehrer work at Wired.

In February 2013, Lehrer offered a public, televised form of an apology at a foundation event, but the highly paid speaking context and the perceived weakness of the apology led to widespread ridicule of his appearance and statements in the press. In March 2013, HMH cleared Lehrer's first book, Proust Was a Neuroscientist, but announced that their internal review found significant problems with How We Decide, leading to recall of this second Lehrer book. Lehrer withdrew from high profile writing and speaking, reemerging in 2015 in a series of public appearances at colleges, reportedly without honoraria, to continue to offer apologies, and to communicate his continuing intention to write and publish, albeit with stricter standards regarding quotation and other past concerns. In the interim, Lehrer began to post blogs on scientific subjects at jonahlehrer.com (beginning March, 2014), indicating that material would be sent for approval to the researchers discussed when possible, or otherwise fact-checked. Lehrer reappeared as a published book contributor in late 2015, with the appearance of The Smarter Screen, a marketing title by behavioural economist Shlomo Benartzi of the UCLA Anderson School of Management, from Portfolio, an imprint of Random House, where Lehrer appears as a contributor on its cover.

Early life, education, employment

Jonah Richard Lehrer was born on June 25, 1981, in the Los Feliz neighborhood of Los Angeles, California. His mother, Ariella (born Jean Hively), a developer of educational software, converted to Judaism to marry his father, David Lehrer, a civil rights lawyer. Jonah Lehrer is reported to have worked as a "line chef" in 2000, at the Midtown Manhattan restaurants Le Cirque and Le Bernardin restaurants, in Manhattan.

College and university

Lehrer graduated from Columbia University in 2003 with a degree in neuroscience. While an undergraduate, he worked in the laboratory of Eric Kandel, "examining the biological process of memory and what happens in the brain on a molecular level when a person remembers or forgets information." He appears on one published paper from that laboratory, as fourth of eight authors on a primary report in a three-laboratory collaborative genetics study characterizing homologs of the human DYRK1A gene from model organism C. elegans, a gene believed to "play a significant role in the neuropathology of Down syndrome."

While at Columbia, Lehrer also contributed to the Columbia Review, and was its editor for two years. Lehrer was a 2003 Rhodes Scholarship recipient, supporting his study at Wolfson College at Oxford University; while he is reported to have planned to study "philosophy, physiology and psychology," he is further reported to have instead studied 20th century literature and philosophy.

Writing career

Print and online periodicals

Lehrer has reported or otherwise written for The New Yorker (July 2008-March 2012; staff writer June 2012), Wired (July 2010-June 2012) Scientific American Mind (June 2008-July 2009), Grantland, The Wall Street Journal, and The Boston Globe. as well as the journal Nature, Seed magazine, and The Washington Post.

Beginning in 2007, Lehrer began contributing editor roles at a variety of publications, including at Scientific American Mind (2009-2012) and for Radiolab (2007-2012, 38 episodes).

Lehrer resigned from The New Yorker on July 30, 2012, after the accusations of fabricated Bob Dylan quotes in Imagine surfaced. On August 31, 2012, Wired.com's editor-in-chief, Evan Hansen, stating Lehrer’s "failure to meet… editorial standards," severed the relationship between that venue and the writer.

Books

Lehrer is the author of three best-selling books: Proust Was a Neuroscientist (2007), How We Decide (2009), and Imagine: How Creativity Works (2012). The latter two of these books have been withdrawn from the market by their publishers after "internal review uncovered significant problems" with the books, where these and other work by Lehrer have been characterised as having misused quotes and facts, plagiarised press releases and authored work, and to have otherwise recycled earlier published work.

List

As of 2016, four books have appeared to which Lehrer is either an author or a cover-presented contributor; two have subsequently been withdrawn.

• Books authored, remaining in print (first hardcopy edition listed):

• Books with contributions not rising to author, in print:

1. Also appearing as Both releases, 6 October.

• Books authored, withdrawn (first hardcopy edition listed):

Descriptions

In print

Proust Was a Neuroscientist is a collection of biographical essays on creative figures such as Marcel Proust, Paul Cézanne, Walt Whitman, and Auguste Escoffier.

Chris McManus, professor of psychology and medical education, University College London, writing in Nature, opens his review, saying "'Oh no he wasn't!' might well be the response to… Lehrer's claim…," continuing to note that while "Lehrer's conceit of the artist as a neuroscientist is not unique" (Semir Ziki and Patrick Cavanaugh having preceded him with the general point), that the "impressions [of artists] are neither experiments nor science" and that the "conceit remains exactly that, if the term ‘neuroscientist’ is to retain any serious meaning." McManus goes on to quote Lehrer, with this analysis:

"What did Proust learn from [the] prophetic crumbs of sugar, flour, and butter [Lehrer asks]? He actually intuited a lot about the structure of our brain." These intuitions included “smell and taste are the only senses that connect directly to the hippocampus, the center of the brain’s long-term memory, [whereas] all other senses are first processed by the thalamus, the source of language and the front door to consciousness”. [McManus concludes:] If indeed Proust intuited this anatomy, it was unfortunate because the taste pathway is wrong, and few regard the thalamus as the source of language...

On a more positive note, McManus notes that "The most interesting parts of Proust… are its manifestos on art and science in the prelude and coda" that begins with C.P. Snow; however, Lehrer proceeds (McManus notes) with "attacks" on Richard Dawkins, Brian Greene, Steven Pinker and E. O. Wilson for failing to engage in a "dialogue of equals" with nonscientists. McManus closes, stating that while Lehrer's notion of a "fourth culture" is a "grand dream," his "attempt at [it] fails" since the neuroscience laid out by Lehrer "seems 'sheer plod', undermining the central conceit—for what artist would partake in such a paltry matter?"

Nonscientists, on the other hand, mostly offered praise for Proust. Science journalist and Guggenheim Fellow D.T. Max described it for the The New York Times as "a precocious and engaging book that tries to mend the century-old tear between the literary and scientific cultures." The review by music critic Helen Brown in The Telegraph stated, "Lehrer is a dazzlingly clever young man whose writing bears witness to both the clarity of his scientific training and the humanity of his literary studies. The Whitmanesque electricity of all the thought and heart he has put into this book fizzes from each sentence." Jonathon Keats at Salon, writing as an artist, approached the "conceit" noted by McManus from the opposing perspective, and described Proust as being written "arbitrarily and often inaccurately".

Withdrawn

In How We Decide, Lehrer argued that two main parts of the brain are involved in decision-making, the rational and the emotional. Steven Berlin Johnson, a technology writer with training in semiotics and English literature, reviewed How We Decide for The New York Times long before its withdrawal from market during the Imagine fabrication scandal (see below), where he wrote:

Explaining decision-making on the scale of neurons makes for a challenging task, but Lehrer handles it with confidence and grace. As an introduction to the cognitive struggle between the brain’s 'executive' rational centers and its more intuitive regions, How We Decide succeeds with great panache.

Adam Kepecs, however, writing in the journal Nature called portions of the book into question based on current understanding of neuroscience.

Before it was pulled from the shelves by publisher Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (HMH), Imagine: How Creativity Works was on the Los Angeles Times' hardcover nonfiction bestseller list for 22 weeks. While Michiko Kakutani of the The New York Times called Lehrer adept for Imagine's "teasing out… social and economic implications of scientific theories while commuting easily among the realms of science, business and art…" noting that "[h]e deconstructs the creative process behind a Bob Dylan song with the same verve he brings to the story of how Procter & Gamble created the Swiffer, its New Age mop… ." Christopher Chabris, writing in the The New York Times Book Review derided Imagine for its "many elementary errors" and formulaic approach, as well as for "Lehrer's failure to grasp some fundamental principles of scientific thinking." A review by Michael S. Roth in The Washington Post said, "Lehrer practices what he preaches, showing an appetite for learning, a determined effort to cross fields and disciplines, and a delight in exploring new possibilities," while Isaac Chotiner of The New Republic described Imagine as inaccurate, simplistic, and glib, and concluded "Lehrer writes self-help for people who would be embarrassed to be seen reading it."

Awards and recognition

While at Columbia University, Lehrer received Columbia's Dean Hawkes Memorial Prize in the Humanities, in a tie for second place for that award.

Plagiarism and quote fabrication scandal

Findings of self-plagiarism

On June 19, 2012, Joe Coscarelli of New York Magazine and Josh Levin of Slate reported that several The New Yorker blog posts by Lehrer had reused significant, identical portions of his own work without acknowledging having done so, referring to the practice as "self-plagiarism." Additionally, Edward Champion reported that portions of Imagine: How Creativity Works had been published previously in various forms by Lehrer, and that he had subsequently re-used parts of his books, unattributed, in further submitted publications, e.g.

• [Lehrer's] Proust Was a Neuroscientist (2007), p. 185:

“The most mysterious thing about the human brain is that the more we know about it, the deeper our own mystery becomes.”

• [Lehrer's] Review of Out of Our Heads, by Alva Noë. The San Francisco Chronicle (March 1, 2009):

“The most mysterious thing about the human brain is that the more we know about it, the deeper our own mystery becomes.” [italics added]

All five of the The New Yorker blog posts now appear on the magazine's website with editor's notes listing where Lehrer had previously published related sentences, a list that included The Wall Street Journal, The Boston Globe, Wired, and The Guardian. In a response soon after, a spokesperson for Lehrer's publisher, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (HMH), stated: "[Lehrer] owns the rights to the relevant articles, so no permission was needed. He will add language to the acknowledgments noting his prior work." Lehrer apologized for this unattributed reuse of his own work. In a related and contemporaneous matter of journalistic malpractice, a correction was appended to a Lehrer article on The New Yorker website published on January 30, 2012, noting that quotations published in the original version of that article had been taken from the work of another writer, Peter Dizikes, at another publication, the MIT Technology Review (i.e., without permission or attribution).

Imagine fabrications, The New Yorker resignation

The seriousness of the disclosures then further escalated. Some weeks later, Michael C. Moynihan reported in Tablet Magazine that Lehrer had fabricated quotes attributed to singer Bob Dylan in his book Imagine, Moynihan's discovery of which he discussed at length with Mark Colvin, host of Australia's ABC News' program Friday Late. Moynihan noted later that the quotations immediately sounded phoney to him when he read the book: they "sounded like a Dylan self-help book," leading him to seek clarification from Lehrer and Dylan's manager. In a subsequent statement, Lehrer admitted, "The quotes in question either did not exist, were unintentional misquotations, or represented improper combinations of previously existing quotes." He also acknowledged having initially lied about the sources for these quotes to Moynihan when first confronted about them.

Lehrer resigned from The New Yorker on July 30, 2012 in the wake of the revelations, less than two months after he had joined the staff. and cancelled or had cancelled several upcoming speaking engagements. In the days and weeks that followed, reporting on the scope of the issues, and related criticism, continued. Colleen Curry of ABC News in the U.S. compared Lehrer in mid-July to "Publishing's... Notorious Offenders," Janet Cooke, Stephen Glass, and Jayson Blair.

Recall of Imagine

Lehrer's publisher, for Imagine and for his two other major works, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, announced that unsold print copies of the book would be recalled and sales of e-books would be suspended. HMH was subsequently reported, in early August, to have placed all of Lehrer's books that they had published under an internal review.

Broadened review and consequences

On July 31, 2012, New York Public Radio issued a statement, calling Lehrer "a talented and valued colleague" and expressing that they were "deeply saddened by the news" of the preceding week, further addressing Lehrer's role as a contributing editor there, between 2007 and 2012. The statement suggested that his work at this NPR venue was untainted, because of their applied journalistic oversight. The substance of their statement was

Jonah Lehrer has been a regular contributor to Radiolab as an "explainer," making technical science more accessible and bringing much needed meaning to new scientific research. He has been a lively and compelling voice and has helped make the history of science come alive for listeners… Radiolab has not used Jonah as a standalone authority on any topic within an episode. Rather, he has brought new research to the attention of the program and the producers in turn have interviewed primary sources and researchers, weaving the voices together as part of a choir—a style of reporting that defines Radiolab. Since Jonah has not been in the role of reporter for Radiolab and we have employed standard practices of journalism in producing the episodes, we have no reason to believe his work with Radiolab is compromised. But we will review the work as needed.

The final episode to which Lehrer is seen to contribute, "The 'Decline Effect' and Scientific Truth," which aired on June 29, 2012, bears a comment indicating audio editing to make two corrections to content—one to a factual quantitative statement, the second to an attribution of a quote—without reference to any individual at the program bearing responsibility. On August 10, 2012, Steve Myers at Poynter.org reported that a quotation from the magician Teller of the performance duo Penn and Teller that had been included in Imagine was inaccurate, but that a previous version of the quote, which Lehrer had used for a 2009 Wired magazine article, had been accurate. In the wake of the disclosures, Wired.com asked journalism professor Charles Seife to investigate Lehrer's posts to its website. Writing in Slate.com (after Wired.com declined to publish his findings), Seife stated that he had found 17 of a sample of 18 Lehrer posts to contain rampant, longstanding recycled work, as well as plagiarism of press releases and of authored work, and issues with misuse of quotes and facts. He summarized his findings in this way:

I am convinced that Lehrer has a cavalier attitude about truth and falsehood. This shows not only in his attitude toward quotations but in some of the other details of his writing. And a journalist who repeatedly fails to correct errors when they're pointed out is, in my opinion, exhibiting reckless disregard for the truth. / It is thus my opinion that Lehrer plagiarized others' work, published inaccurate quotations, printed narrative details that were factually incorrect, and failed to address errors when they were pointed out.

On August 31, 2012, Wired.com's editor-in-chief, Evan Hansen, stated: "Lehrer’s failure to meet WIRED editorial standards leaves us no choice but to sever the relationship."

As well, reports appeared indicating the systematic cancellation of Lehrer's many scheduled speaking engagements, including addresses to the Holmes Report’s Global Public Relations Summit and Iowa State University's College of Engineering, a ticketed book signing at the Aliso Creek Inn in Laguna Beach, California, and an appearance as a part of the Robert Simpson Charles Lectureship in Ethics at Earlham College.

Affirmation of Proust, recall of How We Decide

By March 2013, Lehrer’s first book, Proust Was a Neuroscientist (2007), was found by his publisher, HMH, to be without significant problems, and would remain in print. However, adding to the mounting disgrace of the Imagine recall and severed ties with The New Yorker and Wired.com, Lehrer’s publisher announced at the same time that his second book, How We Decide, would also be pulled.

Apologies

File:Jonah Lehrer Knight Foundation speech.jpg

Jonah Lehrer, February 2013, Knight Foundation paid apology speech. As described in the text, the speech was the occasion of a public apology by Lehrer, which drew significant media disapprobation.

On February 12, 2013, Lehrer gave a paid speech to the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation; entitled "My Apology," his speech included the following content:

I am the author of a book on creativity that is best known because it contained several fabricated Bob Dylan quotes. I committed plagiarism on my blog, taking, without credit or citation, an entire paragraph from the blog of Christian Jarrett. I lied, repeatedly, to a journalist named Michael Moynihan to cover up the Dylan fabrications.

Lehrer also announced plans to continue writing, and spoke of potential safeguards to prevent similar lapses in judgment and accuracy from recurring; at one point he stated, "I need rules." The Knight Foundation acknowledged offering Lehrer a $20,000 fee for the speaking event, which he had accepted.

Various media commentators have criticized the speech, arguing that Lehrer did not express sufficient regret and finding Lehrer's attempts to use neuroscience to discuss his conduct evasive and misleading. Daniel Engber wrote in Slate that the speech "was couched in elaborate and perplexing disavowals." Joseph Nocera of The New York Times wrote that "As apologies go, it was both arrogant and pathetic." Michael Moynihan, who broke the Imagine fabrication story, is reported (by Jon Ronson, see below) as having described it as "a string of Gladwellian bullshit." The day after the speech, the foundation issued a statement acknowledging that Lehrer's fee was "simply not something Knight Foundation, given our values, should have paid."

As of March 2015, Lehrer appears to be offering a repeating form of apologia for his misconduct, at student fora, for which he is reported to not be receiving honoraria, according to a report in the Fresno State University student publication, The Collegian; at one such forum at Fresno State, Lehrer stated that his large workload led to "very serious mistakes. I was taking on more projects than I could handle." With regard to the Dylan quotes he admits to having fabricated, Lehrer specifically cites the pressure he felt from the deadline to finish Imagine. Lehrer now states that he "records all his interviews for reference" and "sends interview subjects the quotes he plans to use."

Ronson's So You've Been Publicly Shamed

The controversy surrounding Lehrer's misuse of Bob Dylan quotes in Imagine and his February 2013 speech to the Knight Foundation figure heavily in Jon Ronson's 2015 book, So You've Been Publicly Shamed. Ronson argues that the media response to Lehrer's journalistic malpractice amounts to shaming, and that is extreme and overdone. Ronson's conclusions are to the consternation of media commentators, who argue that the media has not been "too hard." In assessing Ronson's book in March 2015, Daniel Engber of Slate.com argues that Lehrer's Knight Foundation apology (see above) and Ronson's view of Lehrer's actions and of the apology fail to address the full scope of Lehrer's malpractices; Engber states

Lehrer’s transgressions went much deeper. In Imagine, he didn’t just make up quotes from Bob Dylan; he twisted words and reversed their meanings. (Per Moynihan, for example, he suggests that Dylan had “tantrums of genius” and started tearing up his papers when his writing wasn’t going well. In context, though, that phrase from Marianne Faithfull, quoted in a Dylan book called Behind the Shades, refers not to the singer’s writer’s block but to his sexual frustration.) Lehrer also made up quotes from W. H. Auden and Raymond Teller, and misrepresented their beliefs. He plagiarized widely. (Among the victims seems to have been his erstwhile colleague Malcolm Gladwell.) Lehrer’s publisher hired fact-checkers to look closely at the book, and then it pulled remaining copies from the shelves.

Engber concludes that Lehrer's catalogue of inaccuracy "wasn’t sloppiness or a rash of dumb mistakes. At best, it was a systematic disregard for journalistic ethics. At worst, it was calculated fraud."

Further projects and news

On June 6, 2013, Simon & Schuster announced that it would publish a book by Lehrer with the working title The Book of Love. No publication date has been set. In Slate.com, Daniel Engber suggested that Lehrer might have plagiarized portions of his book proposal from the work of his former New Yorker colleague Adam Gopnik. Both had written about the same episode in the life of Darwin, using the same biography (that of Desmond and Moore) as a source.

Beginning on March 28, 2014, and continuing through April 2016, Lehrer began to post blogs on the scientific subjects that interest him at jonahlehrer.com; in the opening post, "Welcome to my blog," Lehrer thanks his readers, expresses the desire to regain their trust, and indicates that "when possible, all material will be sent to the relevant researchers for their approval. If that’s not possible, an independent fact-checker will review it."

In November 2014, the Associated Press (AP) announced that Portfolio, an imprint of Random House, had acquired rights to a work, then entitled, The Digital Mind: How We Think and Behave Differently on Screens, that was to be "co-written by Lehrer and Shlomo Benartzi," the latter a behavioural economist, and professor and co-chair of the Behavioral Decision-Making Group at the UCLA Anderson School of Management. Adrian Zackheim of Portfolio was reported by AP as stating that while "[n]o responsible publisher could entirely overlook his past mistakes… the prospect of working with him was also fantastically appealing," and as describing Lehrer as "one of the most gifted nonfiction writers of his generation."

The early characterization of the proposed work proved to be inaccurate with regard to the eventual book that was released. Business professor Benartzi is involved with a new Portfolio title that involves Lehrer, entitled The Smarter Screen: Surprising Ways to Influence and Improve Online Behaviour (alternative subtitle, What Your Business Can Learn from the Way Consumers Think Online); Lehrer is listed as a contributor, rather than a co-author—Carlos Lozada of the The Washington Post notes that Lehrer's name appears on the cover "in far smaller type size than Benartzi's name" Lehrer is described by the publisher as "a science writer living in Los Angeles," and only Benartzi's photograph appears on the jacket.

As of April 2015, Lehrer's former book publisher, HMH, continues to display promotional posts for Imagine at Tumblr.

Personal life

Lehrer married Sarah Liebowitz, who accompanied him to England, and who has also worked as a journalist, in 2008; the couple has one child, Rose, born in 2011. Lehrer was involved with the purchase of the historic Shulman House in Los Angeles, California, in 2010.

See also

• Journalistic scandal

External links

• JonahLehrer.com