Demand (psychoanalysis)

From Infogalactic: the planetary knowledge core
Jump to: navigation, search

In the theory of Jacques Lacan, demand (French: demande) represents the way instinctive desires are inevitably alienated through the effects of language on the human condition.[1] The concept of demand was developed by Lacan in parallel to those of need and desire to account for the role of speech on human aspirations.[2] Demand forms part of Lacan's battle against the approach to language acquisition favored by ego psychology, and makes use of Kojeve's theory of desire.[3] Demand is not a Freudian concept.[2]

Language acquisition

For Lacan, demand is the result of language acquisition on physical needs - the individual's wants are automatically filtered through the alien system of external signifiers.[4]

Where traditionally psychoanalysis had recognised that learning to speak was a major step in the ego's acquisition of power over the world,[5] and celebrated its capacity for increasing instinctual control,[6] Lacan by contrast stressed the more sinister side of man's early submergence in language.

He argued that "demand constitutes the Other as already possessing the 'privilege' of satisfying needs", and that indeed the child's biological needs are themselves altered by "the condition that is imposed on him by the existence of the discourse, to make his need pass through the defiles of the signifier".[7] Thus even in speaking one's demands, the latter are altered; and even when they are met, the child finds that it no longer wants what it thought it wanted.[8]


In Lacanian thought, a demand results when a lack in the Real is transformed into the Symbolic medium of language. Demands faithfully express unconscious signifying formations, but always leave behind a residue or kernel of desire, representing a lost surplus of jouissance for the subject, (because the Real is never totally symbolizable).

As a result, for Lacan, "desire is situated in dependence on demand - which, by being articulated in signifiers, leaves a metonymic remainder which runs under it".[9] The frustration inherent in demand - whatever is actually asked for is 'not it' - is what gives rise to desire.[10]

The Other's demands

The demands of human society are initially mediated via the Mother;[11] with the discourse of whom the infant comes to identify, subsuming its own non-verbal self-expression.[12]

The result in the neurotic may be a dominance of parental demand, and of the social objects valued by such demands - jobs, degrees, marriage, success, money and the like.[13] Lacan considered indeed that for the neurotic "the demand of the Other assumes the function of an object in his phantasy...this prevalence given by the neurotic to demand".[11]


Lacan considered that the transference appears in the forms of demands from the patient[14] - demands which he stressed the analyst must resist.[15]

Through such demands, he states, "the whole past opens up right down to early infancy. The subject has never done anything other than demand, he could not have survived otherwise, and...regression shows nothing other than a return to the present of signifiers used in demands".[16]

François Roustang however has challenged the Lacanian view, arguing that the patient's demand, rather than undermining the analysis, may be a positive attempt to get the analyst to shift their therapeutic stance.[17]

See also


  1. A. Lemaire, Jacques Lacan (1979) p. 165
  2. 2.0 2.1 Gabriel Balbo, "Demand"
  3. David Macey, "Introduction", Jacques Lacan, The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis (London 1994) p. xxviii
  4. Alan Sheridan, "Translator's Note", Lacan, Four p. 278
  5. Otto Fenichel, The Psychoanalytic Theory of Neurosis (London 1946) p. 46
  6. Selma H. Fraiberg, The Magic Years (New York 1987) p. 133-4 and p. 115
  7. Jacques Lacan, Ecrits: A Selection (London 1997) p. 286 and p. 264
  8. Stuart Schneiderman, Returning to Freud (New York 1980) p. 5
  9. Lacan, Four p. 154
  10. Philip Hill, Lacan for Beginners (London 1997) p. 66
  11. 11.0 11.1 Lacan, Ecrits p. 321
  12. Gabriel Balbo "Demand"
  13. Bruce Fink, The Lacanian Subject (Princeton 1997) p. 189 and p. 87
  14. Lacan, Four p. 235
  15. Lacan, Ecrits p. 276
  16. Lacan, Ecrits p. 254-5
  17. Jan Campbell, Psychoanalysis and the Time of Life (2006) p. 84