General Dynamics Corp. v. United States
| General Dynamics Corp. v. United States | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|||||
| Argued January 18, 2011 Decided May 23, 2011 |
|||||
| Full case name | GENERAL DYNAMICS CORPORATION, Petitioner v. UNITED STATES | ||||
| Docket nos. | 09–1298 | ||||
| Citations | 563 U.S. 478 (more) | ||||
| Prior history | On Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit | ||||
| Court membership | |||||
|
|||||
| Case opinions | |||||
| Majority | Scalia, joined by unanimous | ||||
General Dynamics v. United States, 563 U.S. 478 (2011), is a U.S. Supreme Court case in which the State Secrets Privilege prevented the plaintiff from using the evidence it needed to protect itself from an expensive judgement.
Background
In 1988 the U.S. Navy ordered a new stealth aircraft, the A-12 Avenger, to be built by contractors General Dynamics and McDonnell Douglas. In 1991 the Navy gave up and cancelled the contract, saying too little progress had been made, and asked the contractors to return payments already made. The contractors refused, saying the government had kept too much information secret under the "state secrets privilege" for there to be adequate progress.[1]
The manner in which the program was canceled led to years of litigation between the contractors and the Department of Defense over breach of contract. On 1 June 2009, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled that the U.S. Navy was justified in canceling the contract. The ruling also required the two contractors to repay the U.S. government more than US$1.35 billion, plus interest charges of US$1.45 billion. Boeing, which had merged with McDonnell Douglas, and General Dynamics vowed to appeal the ruling.[2]
In September 2010, the U.S. Supreme Court said it would hear the arguments of the two companies that the government canceled the project improperly and that the use of a state secrets claim by the U.S. prevented them from mounting an effective defense.[3]
Opinion of the Court
In May 2011, the Supreme Court set aside the Appeals Court decision and returned the case to federal circuit court.[4] The court unanimously held that "when litigation would end up disclosing state secrets, courts may not try the claims and may not award relief to either party."[5]
In January 2014, the case was settled with Boeing and General Dynamics agreeing to pay $200 million each to the U.S. Navy.[6]
See also
- List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 563
- United States v. Reynolds
- Declassification
- Classified information in the United States
References
- ↑ General Dynamics Corp. v. United States (09-1298); Boeing Company v. United States (09-1302) at Cornell Law School's Legal Information Institute site
- ↑ "Court upholds Navy cancellation of A-12 aircraft"[dead link]. Associated Press via thefreelibrary.com, 2 June 2009. Retrieved: 26 February 2011.
- ↑ Liptak, Adam. "Supreme Court Takes Cases on Corporations' Rights". The New York Times, 28 September 2010. Retrieved: 28 September 2010.
- ↑ Weisgerber, Marcus. "Supreme Court Overturns A-12 Ruling Against Contractors". Defense News, 23 May 2011.
- ↑ General Dynamics Corp. v. United States at SCOTUSblog
- ↑ "UPDATE 1-Boeing, General Dynamics reach $400 mln A-12 settlement with U.S. Navy". Reuters, 23 January 2014.
See also
External links
- OPINION AND ORDER from 1998 case of McDonnell Douglas and General Dynamics v. United States, on Federation of American Scientists site
- Aaron D. Van Oort; Marie E. Williams. Supreme Court Decides General Dynamics Corp. v. United States. 23 May 2011.
- Summary of case from oyez.org
